Black spruce thinning treatments come of age

In the early days of fire fuel treatments 25 years ago an experiment was conducted to investigate whether thinning Alaska interior black spruce stands could moderate fire behavior and what would happen to these fuel treatments over time.  Partners Tanana Chiefs Corporation, Alaska Fire Service, and Alaska Department of Forestry conducted operational fuel treatments at 3 sites and the Joint Fire Science Program sponsored the research and monitoring portion of the experiment.  What do these treatments look like now, and how have conditions changed over time?  We had the opportunity to revisit and re-measure one of the demonstration sites recently with fire ecologist Eric Miller of the Wildland Fire Service—this one near the Gerstle River east of Delta Junction. 

The thinned stands today (left) have filled in a little with spruce, both young trees and crown expansion, since thinning but are open and park-like.  The retain the forest character but with more willows and caribou moss (lichens) replacing some of the feather underneath the trees.  The forest floor organic layer is thinner by half and the depth to frost much deeper.  Look at the difference compared to the untreated “control” plot nearby!

Rethinking Fire Fuel Treatments for Multiple Use

Alaskans know we must live with fire. A new open-access article in iScience synthesizes recent fuel break research from Alaska and Yukon, drawing on input from rural community representatives and scientists alike. The study presents a compelling case: fuel breaks designed with “co-benefits” can add ecological and socio-economic value while increasing social acceptance. The research highlights opportunities to move beyond traditional fuel break approaches toward more adaptive and ecologically informed designs. These innovations include tailoring fuel breaks to local vegetation, integrating them with natural landscape features, and aligning placement with suppression and community protection goals.

Drawing illustrating ideas for multiple use benefits on a fire fuel break.

Citation: Link, NT; JF Johnstone, XJ Walker, F Amundsen, HK Berrios, L Bibeau, K Cooley, AC Erickson, C Johnston, JM Little, N Lowjewski, AD Perrin, CA Phillips, S Potter, DC Rees, LB Saperstein, JE Schmidt, EE Sousa, KV Spellman, A Spring, and MC Mack. 2025. Mitigating increasing wildfire risk through fuel break innovations. iScience. Open Access.

Image credit: Victor Leshyk, Center for Ecosystem Science and Society, Northern Arizona University

Wildfires are becoming larger and more severe as the climate shifts in the far north. Fuel breaks are a tool to proactively mitigate risk, but they are expensive, require maintenance, and come with side effects that are sometimes unwelcome to locals. Is there a better path forward?

The Fuel Breaks with Benefits project addresses this question, exploring benefits to communities and ecosystems that could make fuel break planning more effective and appealing. The project established a network of northern experts from many knowledge systems and sectors in Alaska, Yukon, British Columbia, and Northwest Territories to assess opportunities for developing fuel reduction treatments with sustainable social-ecological benefits in boreal forests. The authors emphasize that fuel breaks are not a standalone solution—they are most effective when combined with broader wildfire management strategies, including land-use planning, community preparedness, and fire-smart development practices.

Fuel Treatments Aid 2015 Firefighting Efforts in Alaska

A new report by USFWS Kenai Refuge fire staff (Nate Perrine) examines

Capture-cardst

areas where the 2015 Card Street fire intersected completed fuels treatments. He utilized IFTDSS (Interagency Fuels Treatment Decision Support System) modeling to analyze the treatment effect on fire behavior, and also documented post fire effects within the treated areas. This well-illustrated discussion includes recommendations for future treatments and analyses–a must-read for fire fuels specialists in Alaska! Click below to download a pdf.

The Effects and Use of Fuel Treatments during the Card Street Fire